Good morning. It’s Tuesday, November 17, and this week’s ESG Litigation Weekly covers Norway’s Supreme Court ruling invalidating decisions maintaining three North Sea project approvals, the EU Court of Justice’s dismissal of Poland’s seven challenges to Fit for 55 climate measures, UK advertising rulings finding carbon-neutral and carbon-positive delivery claims misleading, and more.
⚖️ ESG Casefile
Norway Supreme Court Upholds Invalidation of Three North Sea Project Approvals
Norway’s Supreme Court upheld a ruling invalidating government decisions maintaining approvals for the Breidablikk, Tyrving, and Yggdrasil oil and gas developments in the North Sea. In its November 13 judgment, the court unanimously held that environmental impact assessments must account for emissions from burning extracted oil and gas and their effects on global warming. A 6–5 majority further required consideration of cumulative emissions from other existing and approved projects on Norway’s continental shelf, which the subsequent assessments had not addressed. The court did not require assessments of specific consequences of the resulting warming or comparisons with remaining carbon budgets. The court also required authorities to assess whether the planned activities were compatible with national and international obligations to take effective measures to prevent harmful effects of climate change. Because the oil companies were not parties to the proceedings, the ruling does not automatically revoke their permits. The government must reconsider the approvals through a legally adequate process.
🔗 Read more → Norwegian Supreme Court (Press Release, Court Judgment), Greenpeace (Press Release)
EU Court Dismisses Poland’s Seven Challenges to Fit for 55 Climate Laws
The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) dismissed seven actions brought by Poland seeking to annul measures under the EU’s Fit for 55 legislative package, including emissions trading reforms, the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM), vehicle emissions standards, and energy efficiency requirements. Poland argued, among other grounds, that certain measures were essentially fiscal or affected its energy supply and should therefore have required unanimous Council approval. In its November 12 judgments, the court held that the measures could be adopted through the ordinary legislative procedure. It rejected Poland’s challenges concerning their legal basis and other grounds, including proportionality and equal treatment.
🔗 Read more → CJEU (Press Release), InfoCuria (Court Judgments: C-442/23, C-444/23, C-445/23, C-451/23, C-505/23, C-512/23, C-771/23)
Ninth Circuit Partly Backs Challenge to California Climate Disclosure Laws
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit partially reversed a lower court’s denial of preliminary relief in a challenge to California’s corporate climate disclosure laws. In its November 9 opinion, the court declined to block SB 253’s Scope 1 and 2 reporting requirements, covering direct emissions and emissions from purchased energy. It found those requirements would likely withstand First Amendment scrutiny. However, it found Scope 3 value-chain emissions reporting and SB 261’s climate-related financial risk disclosures likely unconstitutional because they compel noncommercial speech and fail strict scrutiny. The court remanded for further proceedings, including whether SB 253’s Scope 3 provisions can be severed. The opinion concerns preliminary relief and does not finally resolve the laws’ constitutionality.
🔗 Read more → Ninth Circuit (Court Opinion)
ExxonMobil Subsidiaries Challenge EU Carbon Storage Obligations in Investment Arbitration
According to Euronews, three ExxonMobil subsidiaries filed a notice of arbitration against the EU under the Energy Charter Treaty, challenging carbon storage obligations under the Net-Zero Industry Act. The legislation requires qualifying oil and gas producers to contribute to the EU’s target of at least 50 million metric tons of annual CO₂ injection capacity by 2030. The companies allege breaches of treaty protections concerning fair and equitable treatment, nondiscrimination, and expropriation. They also argue that permitting delays and high costs make compliance impracticable. Euronews reported that the subsidiaries intend to seek provisional measures suspending the obligations as they apply to the affected subsidiaries, while the European Commission is reviewing the arbitration notice.
🔗 Read more → Euronews (News Article)
South Korean Youth Seek Injunction Against POSCO Blast Furnace Refurbishment
Solutions for Our Climate (SFOC) announced that five young South Koreans have sought an injunction to halt POSCO’s planned full refurbishment of Gwangyang Blast Furnace No. 2, arguing that extending its operation threatens their environmental rights. Their lawyer says the work could extend the coal-based furnace’s lifespan by 15 to 20 years. Green Steel Civic Action, a coalition that includes SFOC, estimates that operating the furnace for another 15 years could generate at least 137 million metric tons of additional CO₂ emissions. Ten young plaintiffs filed a separate lawsuit challenging the refurbishment in 2025. POSCO maintains that the refurbishment does not disrupt its existing decarbonization plans.
🔗 Read more → SFOC (Press Release)
🏛️ Regulatory / Standards Developments
EU Commission Consults on Sustainability Reporting Assurance Standards
The European Commission launched a targeted consultation on limited assurance standards for sustainability reporting under the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD). Drawing on technical advice from the Committee of European Auditing Oversight Bodies (CEAOB), the proposed approach would adapt International Standard on Sustainability Assurance (ISSA) 5000 to EU requirements, including European Sustainability Reporting Standards (ESRS), EU Taxonomy disclosures, and digital reporting. The consultation seeks feedback on assurance procedures, scope, reporting conclusions, and implementation timing. Under the revised CSRD framework, limited assurance remains mandatory for companies within scope, while the provision for introducing a future mandatory reasonable-assurance requirement has been removed. Responses are due January 18, 2027.
🔗 Read more → European Commission (Press Release, Consultation Page, Consultation Document)
EU Reaches Provisional Deal to Increase Free Carbon Allowances for Industry
The Council of the EU and European Parliament reached a provisional agreement to increase free allowances for certain energy-intensive industries under the EU Emissions Trading System for 2026–2030. The agreement would make available approximately 121 million allowances, comprising 88 million in the Commission’s original proposal, 28 million previously unallocated because installations did not meet requirements concerning energy efficiency audits or climate neutrality plans, and 5 million reserved for sectors particularly exposed to carbon leakage. The changes concern industries covered by the system’s heat and fuel benchmarks, including chemicals, glass, and ceramics. The agreement still requires formal adoption by both institutions.
🔗 Read more → Council of the EU (Press Release)
UK Consults on Deforestation Due Diligence Requirements
The UK government launched a consultation on proposed due diligence regulations targeting illegal deforestation linked to commodity consumption in Great Britain. The proposals cover specified products derived from six agricultural commodities, including cattle, cocoa, coffee, oil palm, rubber, and soy, alongside proposed changes to the existing timber due diligence regime. New requirements would generally apply to relevant businesses with global annual turnover exceeding £1 million in the previous financial year. Smaller businesses already covered by timber rules would retain their existing obligations. Proposed due diligence requirements include geolocation-based traceability, risk assessment, and mitigation. The consultation also addresses annual reporting for forest-risk commodities and its possible extension to timber, alongside civil sanctions and potential monetary penalties. The framework focuses on compliance with relevant local laws, with a possible future transition to a deforestation-free standard subject to further policy and legislative consideration. Responses are due January 17, 2027.
🔗 Read more → UK Government (Consultation Page, Consultation Document)
You know the problem. Now build the fix.
You've spent years close to a broken industry or process. You know exactly what would fix it. But you’ve never had the time or resources to make it happen.
With Lovable, your expertise is all you need. Describe the solution to your problem — a website, a dashboard, an internal tool — and get professional-grade software back. You make every call on how it works, because you're the one who knows what it needs to do.
Start today and take $5 off your first month.
Discount of $5 applies to first month of any paid plan. You need to sign up via this webpage in order to claim the discount. The discount applies to new and returning users without an active paid plan. Terms apply.
🧼 Greenwashing Watch
UK Advertising Regulator Finds Carbon-Neutral and Carbon-Positive Delivery Claims Misleading
The UK Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) upheld challenges to environmental claims in advertisements by Grind, ProCook, Who Gives A Crap, and SportsShoes.com. In rulings published on November 11, it examined claims including “Carbon Positive Delivery,” “Carbon Neutral Delivery,” and “Carbon neutral shipping.” Although the ASA accepted that the claims referred to delivery or shipping rather than the products’ full life cycles, it found that the ads failed to adequately explain whether, and to what extent, the claims depended on carbon offsetting or actual emissions reductions. The ASA concluded that the omissions were likely to mislead consumers and required all four ads not to reappear in the forms investigated.
🔗 Read more → UK ASA (Ruling on: Grind Coffee Roasters Ltd, Procook Ltd, Who Gives A Crap Ltd, B Sporting Ltd t/a SportsShoes.com)
German Court Upholds Ruling Against WMF Over Misleading PFOA-Free Claims
The Stuttgart Higher Regional Court dismissed cookware company WMF’s appeal in a case brought by environmental group Deutsche Umwelthilfe concerning advertising for nonstick frying pans. In its November 5 judgment, the court found that “0% PFOA,” presented alongside statements emphasizing product safety, misleadingly suggested a special advantage over competing products. It explained that the use of perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA) is already generally prohibited under EU law, making its absence a standard legal requirement rather than a distinguishing feature. The ruling upheld an injunction against the claim in the misleading form challenged, even though the statement itself was factually accurate. The court did not grant leave to appeal on points of law.
🔗 Read more → OpenLegalData.io (Court Judgment), Deutsche Umwelthilfe (Press Release)
💡 Insight of the Week
US Survey Finds Support for Accountability Over Oil and Gas Climate Advertising
An Ipsos survey conducted for Boston University among 1,005 U.S. adults found that 59% opposed granting oil and gas companies immunity from lawsuits seeking compensation for climate-related damages, while 18% supported immunity. The survey also found that 83% supported holding oil and gas companies accountable for misleading climate-related advertising, with similar support across political affiliations. Additionally, 79% supported accountability for advertising and public relations agencies creating misleading campaigns, while 71% supported accountability for news organizations producing such campaigns through in-house advertising or branded-content studios. Conducted online on November 4–5, the survey measures public opinion rather than legal responsibility.
🔗 Read more → Boston University (News Article and Survey Summary)
📚 Browse Past Issues
Catch up on previous editions → ESGLitigation.com
🤝 Support & Contact Us
Enjoyed this issue? Please share it with your colleagues.
Have feedback or collaboration ideas? Contact us at [email protected]

